ÄúÏÖÔÚµÄλÖãºÊ×Ò³ÐÂÎÅÖÐÐÄÐÐÒµ¶´²ì

Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Ñо¿×ÛÊö

Ðû²¼ÈÕÆÚ£º
2024-02-13
ÕªÒª

ΪҪº¦´Ê£ºÆ½ºâÉè¼Æ·¨ | ×ÛÊö | Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏ | ³µÕÞ | ¿ªÁÑ | ÐÔÄܲâÊÔ

¸ÄÉÆÖйú·Ã濪ÁѵÄÏÖ×´¡¢Æ½ºâõ辶³µÕÞÓ뿪ÁÑÖ®¼äµÄ¹Øϵ£¬ÕÒµ½¸üÓŵÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÉè¼ÆÒªÁ죬¶ÔÍâÑóÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨¾ÙÐÐÁËÊáÀíÑо¿¡£¸ÅÊöÁËÂíЪ¶û·¨ºÍSuperpaveÉè¼Æ·¨µÄȱ·¦ÒÔ¼°Æ½ºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÉè¼Æ»úÀí¡¢ÆðÔ´ÓëÉú³¤£¬Ã÷È·ÈýÀàƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄ¿´·¨ÓëÄÚÔÚ £»×ܽáƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨»ìÏýÁÏÊÔÑéÆÀ¼ÛÒªÁìºÍÓ¦ÓÃʵ¼ùÏÖ×´£¬µÃ³ö½áÂÛ£ºÂíЪ¶û·¨Ó¦Óý϶ࡢʵ¼ù½Ï³ÉÊì £»ÓÃƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Éè¼ÆµÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÐÔÄܸüÓÅ£¬ÄܸüºÃµØ¼æ¹Ë¿¹³µÕÞÓ뿹¿ªÁÑÐÔÄÜ¡¢ÑÓÉìõ辶ʹÓÃÊÙÃü£¬µ«Ïֽ׶εÄƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨±£´æ¿ªÁÑÊÔÑéÖÐÁѺ۱ê×¼·×Æç¡¢ÊÔ¼þÀÏ»¯±ê׼ȱ·¦¡¢ºöÊÓÖÊÁ¿¿ØÖÆ/ÖÊÁ¿°ü¹Ü(QC/QA)µÈÎÊÌ⡣δÀ´¿É½èÖúƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨ÓÅ»¯ÖйúÏÖÐеÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÉè¼ÆÒªÁ죬ÒýÈëQC/QA£¬Öƶ©ÏìÓ¦µÄ¹æ·¶±ê×¼£¬½â¾ö³µÕÞÓ뿪ÁÑÖ®¼äµÄì¶Ü£¬ÓÐÓõØÌá¸ßÖйú·ÃæµÄʹÓÃÊÙÃü¡£

Ëæ×ÅÖйú¹«Â·ÔËÊäÒµµÄÅÉú³¤£¬¹«Â·½¨Éè×îÏÈÏò¸ßÖÊÁ¿×ªÐÍ¡£¾Ý½»Í¨ÔËÊ䲿ͳ¼Æ£¬2018ÄêβÖйú¹«Â·×ÜÀï³ÌΪ484.65Íòkm£¬±ÈÉÏÄêÔöÌí7.31Íòkm£¬¹«Â·Ñø»¤Àï³Ì¸üÊǵִïÁË475.78Íòkm£¬Õ¼¹«Â·×ÜÀï³ÌµÄ98.2%[1]¡£¹«Â·½¨ÉèËäһֱǰ½ø£¬µ«³µÕÞºÍÁѺÛÈÔÊÇ·ÃæºÜÊÇÖ÷ÒªµÄ²¡º¦ÐÎʽ£¬´ó´óµØ½µµÍÁËÐгµÌñ¾²ÐÔ¡¢õ辶ÑŹÛÐԺͷÃæʹÓÃÊÙÃü[2]¡£ÔÚ´ËÇéÐÎÏ£¬¶Ôн¨Á¤Çàõ辶¾ÍÌá³öÁ˸ü¸ßµÄÐÔÄÜÒªÇó£¬ÔõÑùÑ¡ÓøüÓŵÄÅä±È¡¢Æ½ºâ³µÕÞÓ뿪ÁѵĹØϵ£¬½ÓÄɸüºÏÀí¿É¿¿µÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÅäºÏ±ÈÉè¼ÆÒªÁì¾ÍÏÔµÃÓÈΪÖ÷Òª¡£


Öйú¹ØÓÚÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Ñо¿½ÏÉÙ£¬¸ÃÎÄÖ÷Òª¶ÔÍâÑóÏà¹ØÎÄÏ×¾ÙÐÐϵͳ×ܽᣬ×ÛÊöÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÑо¿ÏÖ×´¡£Ê×ÏÈÐðÊöÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÆðÔ´ÓëÉú³¤ÂöÂç £»Ã÷ȷƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄ¿´·¨ºÍ3Öֵ䷶µÄƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨£¬Í¨¹ýÃÀ¹ú¶ÔƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÓ¦ÓÃʵ¼ù£¬Ïêϸ×ܽáƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨³£ÓõÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϳµÕ޺ͿªÁÑÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÒªÁì¼°ÊÔÑé±ê×¼ £»ºó»ùÓÚ¶ÔÑо¿ÏÖ×´µÄÊáÀí£¬¹éÄÉÏֽ׶ÎÑо¿±£´æµÄȱ·¦ÒÔ¼°¹ØÓÚºóÐøƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÕ¹Íû¡£


ƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÆðÔ´ÓëÉú³¤

ƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÆðÔ´

ÏÖÔÚÏÖÐеÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÅäºÏ±ÈÉè¼ÆÒªÁìÖ÷ÒªÓÐÂíЪ¶ûÉè¼Æ·¨¡¢SuperpaveÉè¼Æ·¨¡¢±´À×·¨ÒÔ¼°GTM·¨¡£ÆäÖг£ÓõÄΪÂíЪ¶û·¨ºÍSuperpave·¨¡£ÂíЪ¶ûÉè¼Æ·¨ÓÉÃÀ¹úÃÜÎ÷Î÷±ÈÖݹ«Â·¾ÖµÄBruce MarshellÌá³ö£¬ÊÇÏÖÔÚº£ÄÚÍâÓ¦Óøü¶à¡¢ÊÖÒÕ¸ü³ÉÊìµÄÉè¼ÆÒªÁ죬ÖйúÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÉè¼Æ¹æ·¶½ÓÄÉ´ËÉè¼ÆÒªÁ죬ÆäÓŵãÊÇÊÔÑéÒªÁì¼òÆÓ¡¢¾­¼Ã£¬Ë¼Á¿µ½Á˸ßÎÂÁ÷±äÌØÕ÷[3]¡£Ëæ×Åʱ¼äÍÆÒÆ£¬ÃÀ¹úÐí¶àÖÝ·¢Ã÷ËäÈ»ÂíЪ¶ûÉè¼Æ·¨Ïà¶ÔÀ´Ëµ¿¹ÁÑÐÔÄÜÌåÏÖÓÅÒ죬µ«ÎÞ·¨½ÏºÃµØ¿ØÖƳµÕÞ[4]¡£´ó×Úʵ¼ù֤ʵ£¬ÊÒÄÚÂíЪ¶ûÊÔÑéЧ¹û³£·ºÆðÃܶȺÍÎȹ̶ÈËæÁ¤ÇàÓÃÁ¿µÄÔöÌíûÓÐÏÔ×Å·åÖµ¡¢åÐÒ£ÂÊƫС»ò¹ý´ó¡¢¿óÁϼä϶ÂÊÆ«µÍµÈÇéÐΣ¬¹Å°åÂíЪ¶ûÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÕû¸öÖ¸±êϵͳÓë»ìÏýÁϵÄ·ÓÃÐÔÄܵĹØÁªÐԽϲ¶Ô·Ãæ½á¹¹µÄÖÖÖÖÆÆËðÕ÷ÏóÒ²²»¿ÉÆðµ½ÓÐÕë¶ÔÐԵķÀÖÎ×÷ÓÃ[5]¡£


ΪÁËÄܸüºÃµØÑÓÉì·ÃæÊÙÃü£¬ÃÀ¹ú¹«Â·Õ½ÂÔÑо¿ÍýÏë(SHRP)¿ª·¢ÁËSuperpaveÉè¼Æ·¨£¬SuperpaveÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÉè¼Æϵͳ±»¸¶ÓëÁË3¸öˮƽ£¬Ïֽ׶ÎÖ÷ÒªÓ¦ÓÃˮƽ1ÒªÁ죬ˮƽ2Óëˮƽ3ÒòÊÔÑé×°±¸ÌÚ¹ó¡¢Éè¼ÆÀú³ÌÖØ´óµÈÔµ¹ÊÔ­ÓÉδ»ñµÃÆÕ±éʵÑé[6]¡£ÔçÆÚSuperpaveÉè¼ÆϵͳÖУ¬¸ü×¢ÖØÌá¸ßõ辶µÄ¿¹³µÕÞÐÔÄÜ£¬Ðí¶àÖݵĽ»Í¨²¿·ÖÒªÇóÔÚÖиßÆ·¼¶Â·ÃæÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÉè¼ÆʱÔöÌí¿¹³µÕÞ²âÊÔ¡£ÁíÍ⣬ƾ֤SuperpaveÉè¼Æ·¨ÅÌËã»ñµÃµÄ·ÃæµÍθßÓÚÏÖ³¡Â·ÃæÏÖʵÆøΣ¬Òò´ËSuperpaveÉè¼Æ·¨ÖÐÅÌËã·ÃæÉè¼ÆµÍζȵĹ«Ê½ÊÇ·ñ׼ȷ»¹ÖµµÃÉÌÌÖ£¬ÕâҲʹµÃʹÓÃSuperpaveÉè¼Æ·¨Éè¼ÆµÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÔÚµÍÎÂÐÔÄÜ·½Ãæ±£´æȱÏÝ[7]¡£½ü10ÄêÖУ¬ÃÀ¹ú´ó²¿·ÖÖݵĽ»Í¨²¿·ÖÌåÏÖÏÖÔÚµÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÉè¼ÆÒªÁì²»¿É°ü¹Ü»ìÏýÁϵÄÐÔÄÜ£¬ÇÒ·Ãæ³µÕÞÏÕЩ±»Ïû³ý£¬¿ªÁѳÉΪӰÏìÁ¤Çà·ÃæÊÙÃüµÄÖ÷ÒªÒòËØ[8]¡£Òò´Ë£¬´ó²¿·ÖÖÝƾ֤AASHTO SuperpaveÉè¼Æ±ê×¼µ÷½âÁËÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÉè¼ÆÒªÇó£¬ÒÔÇóÌá¸ßÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϵÄÄ;ÃÐÔ£¬µ«SuperpaveÉè¼ÆÒªÁìµÄ΢µ÷(½µµÍÉè¼ÆåÐÒ£ÂÊ¡¢½µµÍѹʵˮƽ)ÎÞ·¨´Ó»ù´¡ÉϽâ¾ö·ÃæÄ;ÃÐÔϽµ(¿ªÁÑ)µÄÎÊÌ⣬ʹµÃ¸÷ÖÝ×îÏÈÑ°ÕÒ¸ü¿Æѧ¡¢¿É¿¿µÄÐÂÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÉè¼ÆÒªÁì¡£


2006Ä꣬Fujie ZhouºÍScullionµÈ¶Ô·Ãæ³µÕÞÓ뿪ÁÑÖ®¼äµÄÐÔÄÜƽºâ¾ÙÐÐÑо¿£¬Ìá³öÁË»ùÓÚÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏ¿¹³µÕ޺Ϳ¹¿ªÁÑÄÜÁ¦À´È·¶¨zui¼ÑÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿µÄƽºâÒªÁ죬ÕâÒ²ÊǺÜÊÇÔç¹ØÓÚÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÑо¿[9] £»Ëæºó£¬ScullionºÍXiaodi HuµÈ½èÖú´ËÒªÁì¾ÙÐÐÁËÕÖÃæ²ãÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϵÄÅäºÏ±ÈÉè¼Æ£¬²¢ÆÌÉèÊÔÑé·£¬ÔÚ2011Ä꽫Ñо¿Ð§¹û¾ÙÐÐÁËÏÖʵÔËÓÃ[10] £»2012Ä꣬Walubita ºÍXiaodi HuµÈʹÓÃALF¼ÓËÙ¼ÓÔØϵͳ£¬°ÑʹÓÃTxDOT·¨ÓëƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Éè¼ÆµÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϾÙÐÐÁ˱ÈÕÕÊÔÑ飬ÊÔÑé֤ʵ½ÓÄÉƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Éè¼ÆµÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÐÔÄÜÌåÏÖ¸ü¼Ñ[11] £»Í¬Ä꣬Fujie ZhouµÈ¶ÔRAP»ìÏýÁϽÓÄÉÁËƽºâÉè¼Æ£¬ÒÔ´ËÈ·¶¨zui¼ÑÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿[12] £»2013Ä꣬·Ò×˹°²ÄÇÖݽ»Í¨²¿·ÖÌáÒéÐ޸Ĺ淶£¬¶ÔÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϾÙÐÐÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÆÀ¹ÀÀ´Ôö²¹Ìå»ýÉè¼Æ±ê×¼£¬ÒÔ´ËÀ´Æ½ºâ»ìÏýÁϵĿ¹³µÕ޺Ϳ¹Æ£ÀÍ¿ªÁÑÐÔÄÜ£¬ÕâÒ²ÊǺÜÊÇÔç¹æ·¶ÐÔ×ÓµÄƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨[13]¡£ÔÚÖйú£¬·ëоüµÈÔÚ2011Äê½ÓÄɳµÕÞÊÔÑéºÍµÍÎÂÍäÇúСÁºÊÔÑé¶ÔÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϾÙÐÐÁË¿¹¿ªÁѺͿ¹³µÕÞµÄƽºâÉè¼Æ[14]¡£


2015Äê9Ô£¬ÃÀ¹úÁª°î¹«Â·ÖÎÀí¾Ö(FHWA)½¨ÉèÁËƽºâÅäºÏ±ÈÉè¼ÆС×飬Éè¼Æ¿ª·¢Æ½ºâÅäºÏ±ÈÉè¼ÆÒªÁ켰ƽºâ»ìÏýÁÏ¡£2018Äê9ÔÂ⣬ÃÀ¹ú¹ú¼Ò¹«Â·ÏàÖúÑо¿ÍýÏë(NCHRP)Íê³É¿ª·¢Æ½ºâÅäºÏ±ÈÉè¼Æ¿ò¼ÜµÄÏîÄ¿£¬´Ë¾Ù¸üÊÇÅú×¢ÎúƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÖ÷ÒªÐÔ[15]¡£


ƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨¿´·¨ÓëÄÚÔÚ

FHWA½«Æ½ºâÉè¼Æ·¨(Balanced Mix Design£¬¼ò³ÆBMD)½ç˵Ϊ¡°¶ÔÔÚÊʵ±µÄÌõ¼þÏ»ñµÃµÄÊÔÑù¾ÙÐÐÐÔÄܲâÊÔ£¬½â¾ö¶àÖÖ²¡º¦£¬²¢ÇÒ˼Á¿Á˽»Í¨¡¢ÌìÆø¡¢»ìÏýÁϵÄÀÏ»¯ºÍËüÔÚ·Ãæ½á¹¹ÖеÄλÖᣡ±¼ò¶øÑÔÖ®£¬BMD°üÀ¨Á½¸ö»ò¸ü¶àÁ¦Ñ§ÊÔÑ飬Èç³µÕÞÊÔÑéºÍ¿ªÁÑÊÔÑ飬ÒÔÆÀ¹À»ìÏýÁ϶Կ¹³£¼û·Ã没º¦µÄÌåÏÖ¡£


ÏÖÔÚÓÐ3ÖÖ¿ÉÓ¦ÓõÄBMDÒªÁ죺ÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÑéÖ¤Ìå»ýÉè¼Æ¡¢ÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéË¢ÐÂÌå»ýÉè¼ÆºÍÐÔÄÜÉè¼Æ¡£

(1) ÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÑéÖ¤Ìå»ýÉè¼Æ(Volumetric Design with Performance Verification)¡£ÒÔSuperpaveˮƽ1Ìå»ýÅäºÏ±ÈÉè¼Æ·¨Îª»ù´¡ÔÙÔöÌíÌØÁíÍâÐÔÄÜÊÔÑé¡£ÈôÊÇ»ìÏýÁϲ»¿Éͨ¹ýÐÔÄÜÊÔÑ飬¾ÍÒªÖظ´Õû¸öÅäºÏ±ÈÉè¼ÆÀú³Ì¡£ÏÖÔÚÕâÖÖÒªÁìÔÚÒÁÀûŵ˹ÖÝ¡¢Â·Ò×˹°²ÄÇÖÝ¡¢ÐÂÔóÎ÷ÖÝ¡¢µÃ¿ËÈø˹ÖݺÍÍþ˹¿µÐÇÖÝʹÓá£ÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÑéÖ¤Ìå»ýÉè¼ÆÒ»Ñùƽ³£Á÷³ÌÈçͼ1Ëùʾ¡£

Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Ñо¿×ÛÊö

ͼ1 ÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÑéÖ¤Ìå»ýÉè¼ÆÒ»Ñùƽ³£Á÷³Ì


(2) ÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéË¢ÐÂÌå»ýÉè¼Æ(Performance-Modified Volumetric Design)¡£´ËÒªÁìÒ²ÊÇ´ÓSuperpaveÅäºÏ±ÈÉè¼ÆÒªÁì×îÏÈ£¬½¨Éè³õʼµÄ¼¯Áϼ¶ÅäºÍÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿£¬È»ºóµ÷½âÅäºÏ±ÈÒÔÖª×ãÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÒªÇó£¬Éè¼Æ¿ÉÄܲ»Öª×ãËùÓеÄSuperpave±ê×¼¡£¼ÓÀû¸£ÄáÑÇÖÝ¡¢¶í¿ËÀ­ºÉÂíÖÝÏÖÔÚʹÓÃÕâÖÖÒªÁì¡£ÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéË¢ÐÂÌå»ýÉè¼ÆÒ»Ñùƽ³£Á÷³ÌÈçͼ2Ëùʾ¡£

Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Ñо¿×ÛÊö

ͼ2 ÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéË¢ÐÂÌå»ýÉè¼ÆÒ»Ñùƽ³£Á÷³Ì


(3) ÐÔÄÜÉè¼Æ(Performance Design)£ºÕâÖÖÒªÁìÌø¹ýÁËSuperpaveÌå»ýÉè¼Æ£¬Ö±½ÓʹÓÃÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÀ´ÆÀ¹À°üÀ¨²î±ðµÄ¼¯Áϼ¶ÅäºÍÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿µÄ»ìÏýÁÏ¡£´ËÒªÁì¿ÉÒÔΪÁ¤ÇàÍŽáÁϺͼ¯ÁϵÄÐÔÄÜÉ趨µÄµÍÒªÇ󣬹ŰåµÄÌå»ý±ê×¼¿É×÷Ϊ·ÇÇ¿ÖÆÐԲο¼±ê×¼£¬µ«²»¿ÉΪÉè¼Æ±ê×¼¡£´ËÒªÁ컹δ±»Êµ¼ù½ÓÄÉ¡£ÐÔÄÜÉè¼ÆÒ»Ñùƽ³£Á÷³ÌÈçͼ3Ëùʾ¡£

Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Ñо¿×ÛÊö

ͼ3 ÐÔÄÜÉè¼ÆÒ»Ñùƽ³£Á÷³Ì

Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨¾ÍÊÇÒªÔÚ³µÕÞ¡¢¿ªÁÑÖ®¼äÕÒµ½Æ½ºâµã£¬Á¤ÇàÓÃÁ¿Éè¼ÆÊÇÒªº¦£¬Á¤ÇàÓÃÁ¿¹ý¶à£¬ÈÝÒ×±¬·¢³µÕÞ£¬¶ø¹ýÉÙÔòÈÝÒ׿ªÁÑ¡¢°þÂäµÈ¡£Æ½ºâ¼´ÒÔ¸ÕÖª×ã³µÕÞ±ê×¼µÄÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿Îª¸ü´óÖµ £»ÒÔ¸ÕÖª×㿪Áѱê×¼µÄÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿ÎªÐ¡Öµ£¬½éÓÚ´óÓëСֵ֮¼äµÄÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿Öµ¼´´ú±íÁËÁ½ÕßµÄƽºâ¡£¶ø´Ëƽºâ¾ÍÐèÒªÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÀ´¾ÙÐÐÑéÖ¤¡£


ƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨ÏµĻìÏýÁÏÐÔÄÜÆÀ¹À

·ÃæÒªÏëµÖ´ïÉè¼ÆÊÙÃüʱ³¤£¬¾ÍÒªÔÚ½»Í¨ºÉÔغÍ×ÔÈ»ÇéÐÎÌõ¼þÅäÏàÖúÓÃϼá³Ö¿¹³µÕ޺Ϳ¹ÁÑÄÜÁ¦µÄƽºâ¡£Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨ÊÇÔÚSuperpaveϵͳÏ¿ª·¢µÄ£¬ÔÚSuperpaveϵͳÖУ¬¼¯ÁϺÍÁ¤Çàð¤½á¼ÁµÄÅä±ÈÖ÷Ҫȡ¾öÓÚÂÄÀú¼¯ÁϵÄÖÊÁ¿ÌØÕ÷ºÍ»ìÏýÁϵÄÌå»ýÌØÕ÷£¬ÈçåÐÒ£ÂÊ¡¢VMAºÍVFA¡£Ëæ×ÅRAPºÍRASµÄ²ôÈ룬¹ÇÁϱÈÖزⶨ½û¾øÈ·ÐÔÔöÌí£¬Î°èÁ¤ÇàÌí¼Ó¼Á¡¢¾ÛºÏÎï¡¢ÔÙÉú¼ÁºÍÏËάµÄЧ¹ûÔÚÏÖÔÚµÄÌå»ý»ìÏýÉè¼ÆÒªÁìÖÐÒ²ÎÞ·¨ÆÀ¹À¡£Òò´Ë£¬ÐèÒª½«ÐÔÄܲâÊÔ×÷Ϊ»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ³ÌÐòµÄÒ»²¿·Ö£¬²¢ÇÒÔÚÑ¡Ôñ½ÓÄɺÎÖÖÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÆÀ¹ÀʱҪÒÀ¾Ý¶àÒòËØ£¬ÒÔ´ËÈ·±£Â·ÃæÓиüºÃµÄ¿¹³µÕ޺Ϳ¹ÁÑÐÔÄÜ[16]¡£


³µÕÞÔ¤¹À

Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁϵÄÓÀÊÀ±äÐζÔÁ¤Çà·ÃæÊÙÃüÓ°Ïì½Ï´ó£¬½ü¼¸Äê³µÕÞÒÑ»ñµÃÓÐÓõĿØÖÆ£¬µ«ÈÔÒªÔÚƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨³ÌÐòÖоÙÐгµÕÞÊÔÑ飬¶ÔÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϳµÕÞÐÔÄܾÙÐÐÔ¤¹À¡£×ܽáÏÖÔÚÃÀ¹ú¸÷ÖÝÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨ÖеijµÕÞÊÔÑéÒªÁ죬»ñµÃ±í1 £»±í2ΪÃÀ¹úNCHRPÍƼöµÄFNºÍSSTÊÔÑéÐÔÄܱê×¼£¬ÒòÊÔÑé»ú¹¹ºÍ»ìÏýÁϸ÷²»Ïàͬ£¬APAºÍHWTTÊÔÑéÐÔÄܱê×¼Òò¸÷ÖݶøÒì¡£

Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Ñо¿×ÛÊö

±í1 ³£¼ûµÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϳµÕÞÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÒªÁì

Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Ñо¿×ÛÊö

±í2 FNºÍSSTÊÔÑéÐÔÄܱê×¼

·Ò×˹°²ÄÇÖݽÓÄɺº±¤³µÕÞÒÇ(HWTT)ÆÀ¹À»ìÏýÁÏ¿¹³µÕÞÐÔÄÜ£¬11ÖÖ»ìÏýÁϽÓÄÉBMDÒ»ÀàÒªÁì¾ÙÐÐÉè¼Æ£¬40ÖÖ»ìÏýÁϽÓÄÉͨÀý»ìÏýÁÏÌå»ýÉè¼Æ·¨£¬ÊÔÑéЧ¹û±ÈÕյóö£¬½ÓÄÉƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Éè¼ÆµÄ»ìÏýÁϳµÕÞÐÔÄÜÓëÌå»ýÉè¼Æ·¨ÏàËÆ»òÓÐËùÌáÉý£¬ÇÒ¶¼Öª×ã¹æ·¶ÒªÇó[17] £»¼ÓÀû¸£ÄáÑÇÖݽÓÄÉSSTºÍHWTTÅäºÏÑéÖ¤µÄ·½·¨£¬²¢ÔÚÊÔÑéÇ°¶ÔÊÔ¼þ¾ÙÐжÌÆÚÀÏ»¯ £»½ÓÄÉHWTTµÄÉÐÓÐÃ÷ÄáËÕ´ïÖÝ¡¢ÒÁÀûŵÒÁÖÝ¡¢µÃ¿ËÈø˹ÖÝ¡¢Íþ˹¿µÐÇÖÝ¡¢°®ºÉ»ªÖÝ¡¢ÐÂÄ«Î÷¸çÖÝ¡¢ÓÌËûÖÝ£¬½ÓÄÉAPAµÄΪ¸¥ÄἪÑÇÖÝ¡¢ÐÂÔóÎ÷ÖÝ¡¢ÇÇÖÎÑÇÖÝ¡¢¶íº¥¶íÖݼ°ÄÏ´ï¿ÆËûÖÝ[15]¡£


¿ªÁÑÔ¤¹À

¿ªÁѳÉΪ½ü¼¸Äê·Ãæ½á¹¹Ö÷ÒªµÄÆÆËðÐÎʽ¡£SuperpaveµÄÌå»ýÉè¼ÆÎÞ·¨´Ó»ù´¡ÉϽâ¾ö·Ã濪ÁѵÄÎÊÌ⣬ÕâÒ²ÕýÊÇƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Òª½â¾öµÄ½¹µãÎÊÌâ¡£±í3ΪƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Öг£¼ûµÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏ¿ªÁÑÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÆÀ¼ÛÒªÁì¡£

Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Ñо¿×ÛÊö

±í3 ³£¼ûµÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏ¿ªÁÑÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÒªÁì


¿¹ÁÑÐÔÄܲâÊÔÖÖÀà¶àÑù£¬³£ÓõÄÊÇSCBºÍOTÊÔÑ飬Òò½ÓÄÉÊÔÑé²î±ð£¬Ö´Ðбê×¼Ò²²î±ð£¬ÏÂÎÄÏêϸ¸ø³öÃÀ¹ú¸÷ÖÝƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨ÖнÓÄɲî±ð×éºÏµÄÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÒªÁì¼°ÐÔÄܱê×¼¡£


ƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄʵÑéÏÖ×´×ÛÊö

ÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÑéÖ¤Ìå»ýÉè¼Æ·¨

´ËÒªÁìΪƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÒ»ÀàÒªÁ죬ÒÔSuperpaveˮƽ1Ϊ»ù´¡£¬Ò²ÊÇÏÖÔÚʹÓÃÆձ顢¼ò½ÝµÄƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨¡£ÓÐÑо¿Åú×¢£ºÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÑéÖ¤Ìå»ýÉè¼Æ·¨¿Éͬʱ֪×ã³µÕÞ¡¢¿ªÁѺÍÌå»ý±ê×¼[18]¡£Â·Ò×˹°²ÄÇÖݽÓÄÉ´ËÀàƽºâÉè¼ÆÒªÁ죬²¢ÔÚ2013Äê¶Ô±¾Öݹ淶¾ÙÐÐÁËÐ޸ģ¬¹æ·¶ÖÐÊÒÄÚÊÔÑé°üÀ¨HWTTºÍSCB£¬»®·ÖÓÃÓÚÆÀ¼Û³µÕ޺ͳ£ÎÂÏ¿ªÁÑ £»Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏЧ¹ûÏÔʾ£º°´BMD¹æ·¶Éú²úµÄ»ìÏýÁÏ¿¹³µÕÞÐÔÄÜÓÐËùÌáÉý£¬50%ÒÔÉϵĻìÏýÁÏÒ²¾ùÒÑÖª×㿹Áѱê×¼£¬¹æ·¶µÄÐ޸ĶԻìÏýÁϵĿ¹³µÕÞ»ò¿¹Æ£ÀÍ¿ªÁÑÎÞµ¹ÔËÓ°Ïì[17]¡£ÎªÏàʶ¾ö´ó×ÚʹÓÃRAPºÍRAS´øÀ´µÄÎÊÌ⣬ÒÁÀûŵÒÁÖݽ»Í¨²¿ÔÚ2016Äê×îÏȶÔÒ»ÀàBMDÒªÁìʵÑéÑо¿£¬½ÓÄÉHWTT¾ÙÐгµÕÞÆÀ¹À£¬I-FIT¶Ô¿ªÁѾÙÐÐÆÀ¹À£¬²¢ÒªÇó»ìÏýÁÏÒªÖª×ãSuperpaveÌå»ý±ê×¼[19]¡£µÃ¿ËÈø˹ÖÝÒ²½ÓÄÉÒ»ÀàBMDÒªÁ죬´ÓSuperpaveÌå»ýÉè¼Æ×îÏÈ£¬¹ÀËãzui¼ÑÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿£¬Ê¹ÓÃHWTTÀ´ÆÀ¹À»ìÏýÁϵĿ¹³µÕ޺Ϳ¹Ë®Ëðº¦ÐÔÄÜ£¬²¢Ê¹ÓÃOTÀ´ÆÀ¹À¿¹·´ÉäÁѺۺÍ×ÔÉ϶øÏÂÆ£ÀÍÁѺ۵ÄÄÜÁ¦£¬ÔÚÖª×ãHWTTºÍOTÒªÇóµÄÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿¹æģѡÔñzui¼ÑÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿[20]¡£Íþ˹¿µÐÇÖݽ»Í¨²¿ÒªÇó½ÓÄÉDCTÊÔÑéÆÀ¹À»ìÏýÁϵĵÍοªÁÑÐÔÄÜ£¬SCBÊÔÑéÆÀ¹À»ìÏýÁϵÄÆ£ÀÍ¿ªÁÑÐÔÄÜ£¬³µÕÞ½ÓÄɺº±¤³µÕÞÒǾÙÐÐÆÀ¹À¡£


´Ó2006Äê×îÏÈ£¬ÐÂÔóÎ÷Öݽ»Í¨»ù´¡ÉèÊ©Ö𽥶ñ»¯£¬½»Í¨Ìõ¼þÖð²½±°ÁÓ£¬Æ佻ͨ²¿ÓÚ2011Äê×îÏÈΪ¡°ÌØÊâÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏ(¸ßRAP)¡±ÊµÑé»ùÓÚÐÔÄܵÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÉè¼Æϵͳ£¬´ËÉè¼ÆϵͳÓëÒ»ÀàBMDÒªÁìÈç³öÒ»ÕÞ£¬¼´½ÓÄÉAPA²â¶¨ÈÈ°èÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϵijµÕÞÃô¸ÐÐÔ£¬ÓÃOTÊÔÑé²â¶¨»ìÏýÁÏÏÖ³¡¿¹ÁÑÐÔÄÜ£¬²¢ÓÐÒâÔÚºóÐøµÄƽºâÉè¼ÆϵͳÖÐÒýÈëÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÖÊÁ¿¿ØÖÆÀú³Ì[21]¡£Ã÷ÄáËÕ´ïÖݽ»Í¨²¿Ê¹ÓÃ4ÖÖÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿²î±ðµÄ»ìÏýÁÏ£¬Í¨¹ýÒ»ÀàBMD³ÌÐòºÍÐÔÄÜÊÔÑé²âÊÔÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿¶Ô¿¹ÁÑÐԺͿ¹³µÕÞÐÔµÄÓ°Ï죬²¢Ñ¡ÓÃHWTTÓÃÓÚ³µÕÞÆÀ¹À£¬DCTÓÃÓÚ¿ªÁÑÆÀ¹À£¬»ìÏýÁϼä½ÓÀ­ÕÅ¿ªÁѲâÊÔ(Indirect Tension Asphalt Cracking Test, IDEAL-CT)ÓÃÓÚ»ìÏýÁÏÖÊÁ¿¿ØÖƺÍÖÊÁ¿°ü¹Ü(QC/QA)£¬ÊÔÑéЧ¹ûÅú×¢£º½ÓÄÉBMD³ÌÐòÉè¼ÆÁ¤ÇຬÁ¿¸üÄÜ׼ȷµØƽºâ³µÕ޺ͿªÁÑÖ®¼äµÄ¹Øϵ[22]¡£µ½2013Ä꣬¸¥ÄἪÑÇÖݽ»Í¨²¿ÒÑÔÊÐíʹÓÃRAPº¬Á¿¸ß´ï45%µÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏΪ¸ßRAP»ìÏýÁÏÑ¡Ôñ¸ü¸ß¹æ¸ñµÄBMDÉè¼ÆÒªÁ죬ÇÒ×¼±¸ÔÚBMDÉè¼ÆÀú³ÌÖÐÒý½øQC/QA[23] £»Í¨¹ý¶ÔÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÑùÆ·¾ÙÐÐCantabroÄ¥ºÄÊÔÑé¡¢APAÊÔÑé¡¢I-FITÊÔÑé¡¢IDEAL-CTÊÔÑéµÄЧ¹û½ÏÁ¿£¬¸¥ÄἪÑÇÖݽ»Í¨²¿ÔÚBMD³ÌÐòÖÐÑ¡ÓÃAPA²â¶¨ÈÈ°èÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϵijµÕÞÃô¸ÐÐÔ¡¢Cantabro¾ÙÐлìÏýÁϵÄÄ;ÃÐÔ²âÊÔºÍIDEAL-CT²âÊÔ»ìÏýÁÏ¿ªÁÑÐÔÄÜ[24]¡£Öйú£¬2011Äê·ëоüµÈʹÓÃ60 ¡æ³µÕÞÊÔÑéºÍ-10 ¡æÍäÇúСÁºÊÔÑé¾ÙÐÐÁË»ùÓÚ¿¹³µÕ޺Ϳ¹¿ªÁѵÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨µÄÑо¿£¬´ËÒªÁìÓëÒ»ÀàƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨ÀàËÆ£¬ÊÔÑéЧ¹ûÅú×¢£ºÆ½ºâÉè¼Æ·¨±ÈÂíЪ¶ûÉè¼Æ·¨ÄܸüºÃµØƽºâÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϸßÎÂÎȹÌÐԺ͵Íο¹ÁÑÐÔÖ®¼äµÄì¶Ü£¬µ«ÊÔÑéÀú³ÌÖв¢Ã»ÓÐÒýÈë»ìÏýÁÏÖÊÁ¿¿ØÖƺÍÖÊÁ¿°ü¹ÜÀú³Ì¡£ÃÀ¹ú¸÷ÖÝƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨½ÓÄɵÄÐÔÄÜÊÔÑé¼°±ê×¼¼û±í4¡£

Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Ñо¿×ÛÊö

Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Ñо¿×ÛÊö

±í4 ¸÷ÖÝƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨½ÓÄɵÄÐÔÄÜÊÔÑé¼°±ê×¼

ÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéË¢ÐÂÌå»ýÉè¼Æ·¨

´ËÒªÁìÓÉSuperpaveÌå»ýÉè¼Æ×îÏÈ£¬µ«²âÊÔЧ¹û·×Æ罨¶¼Öª×ãSuperpaveÌå»ý±ê×¼£¬ÇÒ½ÓÄɽÏÉÙ¡£¼ÓÀû¸£ÄáÑÇÖݽ»Í¨²¿½ÓÄÉÁ˶þÀàBMDÒªÁ죬³µÕÞÆÀ¹À½ÓÄÉSSTºÍHWTTË«ÖØÊÔÑ飬ÊÔÑéÇ°¶ÔÊÔ¼þ¾ÙÐжÌÆÚÀÏ»¯£¬Ê¹ÓÃSuperpave¼ôÇвâÊÔÒÇÈ·¶¨ÊÔ¼þµÄÓÀÊÀ¼ôÇÐÓ¦±äºÍ»ìÏýÁϵĸնÈ £»¿ªÁÑÐÔÄܲâÊÔ½ÓÄÉBBFÊÔÑ飬ÊÔÑéÇ°¶ÔÊÔ¼þ¾ÙÐкã¾ÃÀÏ»¯£¬È·¶¨Ñ¹ÊµÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϵÄÆ£ÀÍÊÙÃü£¬¼ÓÖÝÏÖÔÚÕý½ÓÄɶþÀàBMDÒªÁìÖÆ×÷ÖÖÖÖÖݼʹ«Â·ÏîÄ¿[25]¡£¶í¿ËÀ­ºÉÂíÖݽ»Í¨²¿ÔÚ2018Äê¶Ô¶þÀàBMDÒªÁì¾ÙÐÐÑо¿£¬»ìÏýÁÏÐè¾ÙÐÐHWTT¡¢I-FIT¡¢CantabroºÍTSR²âÊÔ£¬ÒÔÈ·± £»ìÏýÁÏ·ÓÃÐÔÄÜ´ï±ê £»ÓÃÓÚHWTTºÍTSRµÄÑùÆ·ÐèÀÏ»¯2 h£¬I-FITºÍCantabro²âÊÔÑùÆ·Ðè¾ÙÐкã¾ÃÀÏ»¯£¬µ«È±·¦ÀÏ»¯»ìÏýÁϵÄÊÔÑéÊÒ±ê×¼£¬ÎÞ·¨°ü¹Ü»ìÏýÁÏÀÏ»¯Ë®Æ½µÄͳһÐÔ £»ÆäÖݽ»Í¨²¿Õý¶Ô¸Ã»ìÏýÁϾÙÐкã¾ÃÐÔÄܼà²â£¬ÒÔ´ËÀ´ÓÅ»¯¶þÀàƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨¡£


½áÂÛ

(1) ÁѺۡ¢³µÕÞÊÇÁ¤Çà·ÃæÖ÷ÒªµÄ²¡º¦¡£Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨Äܹ»ÔÚ³µÕÞÓ뿪ÁÑÖ®¼äºÜºÃµØÕÒµ½Æ½ºâµã£¬È÷Ãæ¼æ¹Ë¿¹³µÕÞÓ뿹ÁÑÐÔÄÜ¡£

(2) ƽºâÉè¼Æ·¨½ÓÄɵÄÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÆձ飬²î±ðµÄÐÔÄܲâÊÔÒªÁìÖ´Ðеıê×¼·×Æ磬ÇÒÏÖÔÚҲȱ·¦ÀÏ»¯Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁϵÄÊÔÑéÊÒ±ê×¼£¬Îª¿ØÖÆÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϵÄÖÊÁ¿£¬Ó¦ÔÚBMD³ÌÐòÖÐÒýÈëÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏQC/QAÀú³Ì¡£

(3) 3ÀàBMDÒªÁ춼Äܹ»ÓÐÓõØÌá¸ßÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁϵÄÐÔÄÜ£¬ÏÖÔÚÒ»ÀàBMDÒªÁìʹÓøüΪ¼ò½Ý¡¢Æձ顣¶àÖÖÐÔÄÜÊÔÑéÆÀ¼ÛÒªÁìµÄÍŽáʹÓÃÄܹ»Ê¹Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁϵÄÐÔÄÜÔ½·¢¿É¿¿£¬±ÈÕÕÖйúÏÖÐеÄÂíЪ¶ûÉè¼ÆÒªÁ죬BMD·¨ÓÐןü´óµÄÓÅÊÆ£¬ÊÇδÀ´Öйú»ìÏýÁÏÉè¼ÆÑо¿¹Ø×¢µÄÒªÁìÓëÆ«Ïò¡£


²Î¿¼ÎÄÏ×£º?

[1] ½»Í¨ÔËÊ䲿.2018Ä꽻ͨÔËÊäÐÐÒµÉú³¤Í³¼Æ¹«±¨[N].Öйú½»×ª´ï,2019-04-12.

[2] Ѧ°®Ð£¬Íõ½à¹â,Íõˮʦ£¬µÈ.¸ßËÙ¹«Â·Á¤Çà·ÃæÁѺÛÉú³¤¶Ô·Ãæ½á¹¹ÐÔÄܵÄÓ°ÏìÑо¿[J].ÖÐÍ⹫·,2019,39(3):47-53.

[3] ºÂÅàÎÄ.Á¤ÇàÓëÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏ[M].±±¾©:ÈËÃñ½»Í¨³öÊéÉ磬2009.

[4] Musselman James,Choubane Bouzid ,Page Gale,et al.Superpave Field Implementation: Florida¡äs Early Experience[J].Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board,1998,1 609(1):51-60.

[5] ³Â»ªöÎ,½­ÐÇ.Á¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÂíЪ¶ûÉè¼ÆÒì³£Õ÷ÏóÆÊÎö[J].ÖÐÍ⹫·,2006,26(4):195-197.

[6] NCHRP.The Superpave Mix Design System: Anatomy of a Research Program[R],2012.

[7] ³Âæç,Öì´ºÑô.²î±ðÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏÉè¼ÆÒªÁì±ÈÕÕÆÀ¼ÛÆÊÎö[J].ÖÐÍ⹫·,2007,27(4):267-271.

[8] McCarthy Leslie Myers,Callans Jonathan,Quigely Robert.Performance Specifications for Asphalt Mixtures[R],2016.

[9] Fujie Zhou,Sheng Hu,Tom Scullion.Integrated Asphalt (Overlay) Mixture Design,Balance Rutting and Cracking Requirement[R].Technical Report FHWA/TX-06/0-5123-1,TTI,TX,US£¬2016.

[10] Tom Scullion,Xiaodi Hu,Stephen Sebesta.Design,Construction and Performance Monitoring of the very Thin Overlay Placed on BUS 59 in the Lufkin District[R].Technical Report FHWA/TX-10/5-5598-01-2,TTI,TX,US,2010.

[11] Lubinda Walubita,Xiaodi Hu,Tom Scullion.Laboratory Evaluation of Two Different HMA Mix-Design Methods and Test Procedures[J].Asfaltosy Pavimentos,2012,13(24):4-16.

[12] Fujie Zhou,Sheng Hu,Gautam Das,et al.Successful High RAP Mixes Designed with Balanced Rutting and Cracking Requirements[J].Asphalt Paving Technology: Association of Asphalt Paving Technologists-Proceedings of the Technical Sessions,2012,81(1):477-505.

[13] Standard Specifications for Roads and Bridges[S].Louisiana Department of Transportation and Development,2016.

[14] ·ëоü,²éÐñ¶«,ÍôÎÄÔ¨,µÈ.»ùÓÚ¿¹³µÕ޺Ϳ¹¿ªÁѵÄÁ¤Çà»ìÏýÁÏƽºâÉè¼Æ[J].Î人Àí¹¤´óѧѧ±¨,2011(5):86-89,112.

[15] NCHRP.Auburn,AL: National Center for Asphalt Technology at Auburn University.Development of a Framework for Balanced Mix Design[R],2018.

[16] Fujie Zhou,David Newcomb,Charles Gurganus,et al.Experimental Design for Field Validation of Laboratory Tests to Assess Cracking Resistance of Asphalt Mixtures[R],2015.

[17] Samuel Cooper,Louay Mohammad,Sharear Kabir,et al.Balanced Asphalt Mixture Design through Specification Modification: Louisiana¡äs Experience[J].Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board,2014,2 447:92-100.

[18] Fujie Zhou,Sheng Hu,Tom Scullion,et al.A Balanced HMA Mix Design Procedure for Overlays (with Discussion)[J].Journal of the Association of Asphalt Paving Technologists,2007,76:823-850.

[19] Pfeier,B.A..Illinois DOT Practices for Balanced Mix Design[M].Presented at 97th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board,Washington,D.C.,2018.

[20] Test Procedure for Design of Bituminous Mixtures[S].Tex-204-F.Texas Department of Transportation,2016.

[21] Standard Specifications for Road and Bridge Construction[S].New Jersey Department of Transportation,2007.

[22] Fujie Zhou,David Newcomb,Texas A&M Transportation Institute.Balanced Design of Asphalt Mixtures[R],2018.

[23] Stacey D.Diefenderfer,Benjamin F.Bowers.Initial Approach to Performance (Balanced) Mix Design: The Virginia Experience[J].Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board,2019,2 673:335-345.

[24] USA.Department of Hingways.Road and Bridge Specifications[Z],2016.

[25] Aschenbrener,T..Case Histories of Setting the Job Mix Formula with a Balanced Mix Design Compared to a Volumetric Mix Design[R],2016.



Ïàʶ¸ü¶à²úÆ·ÐÅÏ¢£¬»ñÈ¡²úÆ·×ÊÁÏ£¬½Ó´ý´¹Ñ¯TIPTOP±ÒÓÎ

ЧÀÍÈÈÏß | 400-633-0508? ? ÓÊÏ䣺tiptop@tiptoptest.com

·ÖÏí£º